Shifting Shadows & Silent Reckonings
Day 2
Chapters 8-13
As we begin to settle into Feyre’s new life in Prythian, the tone begins to shift. The woods are quieter, the manor more mysterious, and Feyre—our fierce huntress—is starting to unravel. Chapters 8–13 offer a subtle but powerful pivot in her journey, where instinct meets introspection and survival begins to blur with something more tender.
The Arrow That Echoes: Regret or Realization?
In Chapter 11, Feyre hesitates. A deer crosses her path, and her bow rises out of habit—but she doesn’t shoot. Pre-Andras, she wouldn’t have hesitated in bringing down that deer. But now? Something’s changed.
The group had thoughts:
• Celita: I don’t think Feyre is quite there in her mind and heart to regret killing Andras (yet). I think it is weighing on her, but I think she hesitated because her circumstances have changed, as well as her family’s if Tamlin is to be believed. It wasn’t until she had her nightmare did the gravity of what she had done started to actually weigh her down.
• Krystalyn: I think at the time of killing Andras she was just trying to feed her family and did what she had to do but when she seen that deer with Lucien her circumstances had changed and she wasn’t as eager to kill food for her family.
• QueenCarter4Reads: Circumstantial. She's seeing what Andras meant to his people, and she sacrificed him for an ungrateful family. She's definitely feeling the remorse, now.
• Additional Insight: Feyre’s hesitation isn’t just about morality—it’s about identity. She’s beginning to see herself not just as a hunter, but as someone capable of choice. The arrow she didn’t release speaks louder than the one she did. It’s the first sign that she’s no longer reacting to the world—she’s starting to reflect on it.
This moment marks a quiet turning point. Feyre’s actions are no longer just about survival—they’re becoming about consequence.
Lucien & Feyre: A Budding Bond
With Tamlin off hunting the Bogge (and let’s be honest, being cryptic and broody), Feyre and Lucien are spending more time together. Their banter is sharp, their chemistry undeniable, and beneath Lucien’s sarcasm lies something almost friendly.
We also get a glimpse into Tamlin’s infamous “moods” through Lucien’s lens. The politics of the fae are beginning to surface—unforgiving, hierarchical, and laced with unspoken rules. Disobedience isn’t just frowned upon; it’s punished.
Illiteracy & Injustice
Chapter 12 drops a quiet bomb that was hinted at earlier in the story: Feyre is illiterate. Despite being the sole provider for her family, she was never taught to read. Her sisters—more educated, more refined—never stepped in. Why?
This revelation adds another layer to Feyre’s isolation. She’s not just physically burdened—she’s intellectually excluded. It’s a subtle but powerful commentary on neglect, class, and the invisible wounds that shape her.
Final Thoughts
Day 2 peels back the layers of Feyre’s psyche. Her hesitation, her nightmares, her quiet realizations—they’re all signs that the girl who walked into Prythian with a bow and a grudge is beginning to evolve. The magic is still distant, but the emotional stakes are rising.
Tomorrow, we dive deeper into Tamlin’s secrets and Lucien’s loyalties. Until then, keep your arrows sharp and your hearts open.
Tag your thoughts with #ACOTARBuddyRead and let’s keep the conversation glowing.
